to this topic at least. It is with great relief that I can say that I won’t be posting anything about Joe Pizarchik’s nomination anymore. I don’ t have to. He’s been voted out of committee (pay close attention to what Chairman Bingaman says in the article). What have I learned from this experience? Plenty.
For starters, the Internet has allowed opinion to morph into “authority,” which is a real shame. Granted, newspapers have always had owners and ideologies and leanings one way or another. But am I naive to think that there was a time newspapers could be trusted to provide the facts? When I was a reporter, I always tried to get both sides of an issue represented (no matter what I thought of the issue). So many times, though, I was frustrated by someone who would say, “You won’t get it right so I’m not talking to you.” Even when I explained that the only way to get their voice heard in the debate was for them to talk to me, they wouldn’t listen. And I’d have to write that “Calls to ___ were unreturned” sentence. I hated that.
I also learned that hearing “it’s not personal,” no matter how many times, doesn’t make it so. This was an extremely painful experience for me. I will never understand some people’s motivations for what they did. I’ve certainly lost some of my willingness to trust.
I also lost my willingness to identify myself carte blanche as a liberal. As I’ve said, I thought these were my people, but my people wouldn’t act the way these folks have. So from now on I’m going to do a lot less mass-judgment (of which we are all guilty, of course) and more research and reflection before forming an opinion. I guess that’s a good thing.
And I’ll be using this experience as part of my freshman comp lessons for a while. I think I’ll ask my students to research Joe Pizarchik and see how many of them get to a real, credible source. I think we call that a teachable moment? Ha!
So it’s back to bears and rock stars and birds and marriage, back to music and movies and my dear mother and my dog. And book reviews, of course. Thanks for reading and hope you continue to!